상세 보기
의미의 객관성과 객관적 해석학해석학, 구조주의, 프래그머티즘 의미 이론의 종합 시도와 그 한계
초록
The objective hermeneutics developed by Ulrich Oevermann and his colleagues has been attempting to overcome the limit of hermeneutical and phenomenological theory of meaning and to synthesize the structuralist and pragmatist tradition. The objective hermeneutics criticizes those intellectual traditions that lay one-sided emphasis upon the subjective dimension of meaning, and seeks to reconstruct the concept of the objectivity of meaning that has been articulated by the structuralism and the pragmatism. The ‘objective structure of meaning,’ a central concept of the objective hermeneutics, expresses the thesis that the objective structure of meaning emerges out of the process of social interaction among individual actors who, on their part, construes subjectively intended meaning. The ‘sequential analysis,’ the most important analytical method of the objective hermeneutics, can be understood as a methodic design to find out the inter-subjective structure of meaning beyond the subjectively intended meaning of individual actors. This attempt to synthesize the hermeneutical, structuralist, and pragmatist theory of meaning must be a significant project that requires exact and critical examination. However, it cannot be said that this attempt has been successful. Firstly, the objective hermeneutics gave consideration neither to the long tradition of the ‘hermeneutical objectivism’ nor the theory of the ‘structure of life-world’ of Schütz and Luckmann, and thus exaggerated its originality. Secondly, the objective hermeneutics distorted the theory of George Herbert Mead by arguing as if it were a structuralist one. By putting the creativity of action and the contingency of interaction into the prison of a structural rule, the objective hermeneutics failed to integrate the most meaningful achievement of the intellectual tradition of pragmatism. Thirdly, because of this rigid structural bias, it ruled out systematically the possibility to solve the problems of the structuralist theory of meaning by dint of the hermeneutical, phenomelogical, and pragmatist traditions.
키워드
- 제목
- 의미의 객관성과 객관적 해석학해석학, 구조주의, 프래그머티즘 의미 이론의 종합 시도와 그 한계
- 제목 (타언어)
- Objectivity of Meaning and The Objective Hermeneutics:Critical Assessment of Objective Hermeneutics’ Attempt to Synthesize Hermeneutical, Structuralist, and Pragmatist Theory of Meaning
- 저자
- 신진욱
- 발행일
- 2005-05
- 저널명
- 사회와 이론
- 호
- 6
- 페이지
- 83 ~ 128
- 언어
- KOR
- 출판사
- 한국이론사회학회
- 발행국가
- 대한민국
- 분량
- 46 페이지
- ISSN
- P 1598-6500