상세 보기
해석학의 존재론적 전환과 ‘정당한 이해’의 이상 : 사회과학의 해석적 방법론에 대한 함의
초록
This article makes an internal critique of the philosophical hermeneutics of Hans-Georg Gadamer, who had a strong influence on the contemporary social theory and sociological methodology. It seeks to show that the philosophical hermeneutics that redefined the hermeneutics as an ontology of understanding cannot circumvent the epistemological-methodological questions that have been raised by the modern hermeneutics. Gadamer started from an abstract confrontation between the methodology of interpretation and the ontology of understanding, and argued that the task of hermeneutics has nothing to do with the epistemology or methodology of scientific interpretation, but is to elucidate the ways of being of Dasein and the nature of universal understanding, which goes far beyond the realm of scientific concepts. This kind of ontological turn of hermeneutics has become an important philosophical foundation for various positions which are fundamentally skeptical to any methodological investigations in contemporary social sciences. Former criticisms of this kind of reception of the philosophical hermeneutics centered on the 'limit' of the philosophical hermeneutics, that is, its ignorance of epistemological as well as methodological questions. But this article pays special attention to the 'self-contradiction' inherent in the system of the philosophical hermeneutics. It shows that Gadamer, on the one hand, made a fundamental criticism upon the search for a methodology of interpretation in the modern hermeneutics, while, on the other hand, drew significant epistemological-methodological tasks out of his own ontological arguments. By demonstrating this self-contradiction, this article will make it clear that the reflection on the ontological conditions of scientific recognition does not request the abandoning of methods, but on the contrary a more sophisticated and self-reflexive methodology. The ontological reflection on scientific methods must move on to the methodological reflection based upon such ontological self-reflection.
키워드
- 제목
- 해석학의 존재론적 전환과 ‘정당한 이해’의 이상 : 사회과학의 해석적 방법론에 대한 함의
- 저자
- 신진욱
- 발행일
- 2009-02
- 저널명
- 한국사회학
- 권
- 43
- 호
- 1
- 페이지
- 23 ~ 55
- 출판사
- 한국사회학회
- 발행국가
- 대한민국
- 분량
- 33 페이지
- ISSN
- P 1225-0120