구조해석학과 의미구조의 재구성

Structural Hermeneutics and the Reconstruction of Meaning Structure

초록

This article reconstructs the qualitative method of text analysis by structural hermeneutics(or objective hermeneutics) which has been developed by sociologists in german-speaking countries, with special emphasis on its application to the interpretive reconstruction of meaning structure. The purpose of this study is to link into an integrative process of inquiry its methodological foundation, principles of interpretation, logic of inference, and practical interpretive method which in general have been handled separately. From the methodological perspective the structural hermeneutics aims to reestablish social sciences as textual sciences by way of reconstructing action rules and meaning structures that are realized in the process of individual actions and interactions. The central principle of interpretation to reach this aim is that of a sequential analysis of the interaction process, the subprinciples of which are the stance of purposed naivity toward research objects, the formulation of interpretive hypotheses through a thought experiment, and the principle of precise analysis and explication of linguistic elements of texts. Under these principles the structural hermeneutics combines three logics of inference-hypothetical inference, abduction, and falsification, in order that from a special case its structure of meaning as well as the process of structuration can be reconstructed. In actual research practices, such reconstructive activities follow the procedure that moves from abductive formation of interpretive hypotheses through the comparison of those hypotheses and actual context of action on to a reconstruction as well as generalization of meaning structure. The structural hermeneutical methods of analysis are particularly relevant for studies (a) whose purpose is to analyze the structure and dynamics of social meanings, (b) that are interested in reconstructing the narrative context of a concrete process of interaction rather than in generating a decontextualized general theory, (c) about a very limited amount of research objects that are of striking theoretical or practical significance, and (d) with textual data in which a sequential stream of symbolic interactions are documented.

키워드

질적 연구; 구조해석학; 객관적 해석학; 의미구조; 순차적 분석; 가설창안; qualitative research; structural hermeneutics; objective hermeneutics; meaning structure; sequential analysis; abduction
제목
구조해석학과 의미구조의 재구성
제목 (타언어)
Structural Hermeneutics and the Reconstruction of Meaning Structure
저자
신진욱
발행일
2008-04
저널명
한국사회학
권
42
호
2
페이지
191 ~ 230