근대와 폭력-다원적 복합성과 역사적 불확정성의 사회이론-

Violence and Modernity

초록

The question of violence has long since been marginalized in sociology. Therefore, the military, state, and collective violences of the modern era couldn’t be integrated into a broader social theory of modernity successfully. The aim of this article is to find out the most promising way to theorize the complex and dynamic relationships between violence and other aspects of modernity. This article argues three interpretive theses with reference to the theories of violence in classical and modern sociology. Firstly, within the works of the founders of sociology there exist three competing theoretical paradigms on violence, namely, the marginalization of violence, the use of the concept violence as a metaphor, and the understanding of violence as a sui generis social fact. Secondly, theories of violence developed in contemporary sociology have overcome the tendency to marginalize violence and deepened the theory of ‘violence as metaphor’ and of ‘violence as social fact.’ Thirdly, recent social theories that thematized the issue of violence began with recognizing violence as a social fact with its own material foundations, dynamics and constitutive power. These theories attempted to grasp the relationship between violence and other aspects of modernity in various ways. It is the central thesis of this article that the most successful alternative to grasp the complex relation between violence and other aspects of modernity was those theories that put the plural complexity of modern societies and the historical contingency of various modernization processes to the centre of social theory.

키워드

사회적 사실로서의 폭력; 근대와 폭력; 폭력과 사회이론; 다원적 복합성; 역사적 불확정성; violence as a social fact; modernity and violence; violence and social theory; plural complexity; historical contingency
제목
근대와 폭력-다원적 복합성과 역사적 불확정성의 사회이론-
제목 (타언어)
Violence and Modernity
저자
신진욱
발행일
2004-08
저널명
한국사회학
권
38
호
4
페이지
1 ~ 31