사진의 존재론적 재구성 -지표성 비판과 이언 보고스트의 에이리언 현상학-

The Ontological Reconstruction of Photography -A Critique of Indexicality and Ian Bogost's Alien Phenomenology-

초록

This dissertation diagnoses the ontological crisis of contemporary photography under digital and algorithmic saturation, proposing Ian Bogost’s "Alien Phenomenology" and Object-Oriented Ontology (OOO) as radical alternatives to traditional media theory. For over a century, photographic realism has been anchored in the metaphysics of indexicality, represented by Roland Barthes’s ça-a-été and Charles Sanders Peirce’s semiotics. This study unmasks how these canonical paradigms remain trapped within Quentin Meillassoux’s "correlationism"—an anthropocentric dogma that subordinates the autonomous reality of the world to human perception and interpretation. To overcome this impasse, this study reconfigures photography from human representation to a horizontal "assemblage" of human and non-human units. Utilizing Bogost’s concept of "unit operations," the photographic event is redefined as an independent "object-event" wherein technological agents—including lenses, CMOS sensors, and image-processing algorithms—interact autonomously on a flat ontological plane. The validity of this object-oriented framework is verified through a critical re-examination of Eugène Atget and Thomas Demand. By systematically excising Maurice Merleau-Ponty’s correlationist phenomenology, Atget’s street photographs are reinterpreted through "ontography," revealing a horizontal co-existence of withdrawn objects. Furthermore, Demand’s practice is theorized as "carpentry," making manifest the "passive computation" of algorithmic hardwares and the stubborn return of materiality against idealism. Ultimately, this research shifts the photographic discourse from communicative meaning to operational mechanics, establishing a speculative materialist aesthetic. In its final extension, this study projects its theoretical paradigm onto the contemporary landscape of generative AI and deepfakes, identifying them as the ultimate manifestation of autonomous machine operations. By confronting this technical evolution, the dissertation outlines an ontological defense against the impending epistemic apocalypse, providing a definitive roadmap for post-photographic media philosophy.

키워드

객체지향 존재론; 에이리언 현상학; 지표성; 상관주의; 존재론적 평등; 목공술; 수동적 계산; 으젠트 앗제; 토마스 데만트; Object-Oriented Ontology; OOO; Alien Phenomenology; Indexicality; Correlationism; Ontography; Carpentry; Passive Computation; Eugène Atget; Thomas Demand
제목
사진의 존재론적 재구성 -지표성 비판과 이언 보고스트의 에이리언 현상학-
제목 (타언어)
The Ontological Reconstruction of Photography -A Critique of Indexicality and Ian Bogost's Alien Phenomenology-
저자
이용환
발행일
2026-06
유형
Y
저널명
예술문화융합연구
호
24
페이지
44 ~ 55