When staffing regulation becomes a numbers trap: Nurse shortages in South Korean nontertiary hospitals

Citations

WEB OF SCIENCE

0
Citations

SCOPUS

0

초록

Background: Nurse shortages are increasingly recognized as a problem not only of absolute supply but also of maldistribution. Nontertiary hospitals in South Korea have experienced persistent recruitment difficulties despite various regulatory interventions to ensure adequate nursing capacity. Purpose: To examine how nursing leaders in South Korean nontertiary hospitals recruit and retain nurses under headcount-based staffing regulations, and to explore factors contributing to the recurring nurse shortages in these settings. Methods: This qualitative descriptive study used focus group interviews with 15 nursing leaders directly involved in recruitment and staffing decisions at nontertiary hospitals. Data were collected in August 2022 using a semi-structured interview guide and analyzed using Braun and Clarke's reflexive thematic analysis. Results: Four themes were identified: (1) tertiary hospital dominance and the “black hole” effect, (2) policy trap: headcount-based hiring, (3) the “fragile mosaic”: a hastily assembled workforce, and (4) inevitable collapse: why even the settlers leave. By integrating these themes, we derived a conceptual model explaining how nurse shortages in nontertiary hospitals are structurally produced and why they consistently recur. Conclusion: These findings revealed an unintended regulatory consequence: headcount-based staffing standards applied within the existing South Korean labor markets may incentivize headcount compliance over workforce quality while allowing cost-centered institutional practices to persist unchecked. Policy responses should move beyond headcount alone to address labor-market concentration, incorporate workforce quality indicators such as skill mix and retention capacity, and strengthen institutional accountability for investing in nurses’ education and retention.

키워드

Employee turnover; Focus groups; Nursing staff, hospital; Personnel selection; Qualitative research; MONOPSONY; MORTALITY; EDUCATION
제목
When staffing regulation becomes a numbers trap: Nurse shortages in South Korean nontertiary hospitals
저자
Jeong, Hyo Ju; Choi, Sungkyoung
DOI
10.1016/j.jnr.2026.07.002
발행일
2026-10
유형
Article
저널명
Journal of Nursing Regulation
권
17
호
3
페이지
276 ~ 283