사물의 기호화와 의미의 성립 조건 - 단토의 예술계 이론과 바르트의 신화론 -

The Conditions for the Semiotization of Objects and the Constitution of Meaning : Danto's Artworld Theory and Barthes's Mythologies

초록

This study aims to examine the conditions under which ordinary objects become meaningful signs in contemporary art and everyday culture, through a comparative analysis of Arthur C. Danto's Artworld theory and Roland Barthes's Mythologies. The study proceeds in three stages: it first analyzes Danto's concepts of the "Artworld" and "Embodied Meaning," then examines Barthes's concepts of "myth" (mythe) and démystification, before undertaking a cross-analysis of the structural correspondence between the two theories. The analysis reveals that both thinkers agree that the meaning of objects is constituted not by their physical properties but by external contexts—the theoretical discourse of the Artworld in Danto's case, and the codes of ideology in Barthes's. Danto argues that an object comes to be established as an artwork through the process of embodying a philosophical proposition within the historical and theoretical framework of the Artworld; Barthes, by contrast, exposes how everyday objects function as mythic signs that naturalize ideological intentions as self-evident facts, and proposes démystification as a critical practice of restoring the historical contingency that myth conceals. Both theories share the same underlying structure—external context produces meaning, which then generates an effect of self-evidence—yet they diverge in their theoretical orientation and evaluative direction. The study concludes that asking what conditions make the semiotization of objects possible (Danto) and tracing the historical and ideological construction of those conditions (Barthes) are not mutually exclusive but complementary, constituting two critical practices essential to the understanding of contemporary art.

키워드

아서 단토; 롤랑 바르트; 예술계; 구현된 의미; 탈신화화; Arthur Danto; Roland Barthes; Artworld; Embodied Meaning; Demystification
제목
사물의 기호화와 의미의 성립 조건 - 단토의 예술계 이론과 바르트의 신화론 -
제목 (타언어)
The Conditions for the Semiotization of Objects and the Constitution of Meaning : Danto's Artworld Theory and Barthes's Mythologies
저자
김휘택
DOI
10.24185/SSWUHR.2026.08.54.89
발행일
2026-08
유형
Y
저널명
人文科學硏究
권
54
호
1
페이지
89 ~ 116